Community Comes Together to Mourn Outstanding Teen Hockey Player after Fatal Crash

The streets of Idaho can pose special risks to motorists due to the ice and the hilly conditions. As a result, routine tragedies demonstrate the need for a special brand of care on our roadways. On April 15, 2025, the Idaho Falls community came together to mourn the loss of 17-year-old Carter Barnes, a dedicated hockey player who died in a car crash on April 12 near Shelley. Carter started playing hockey at age four and became a standout in the Idaho Falls Youth Hockey Association. Known for his green gear and wide smile, he inspired teammates and his younger brother, Mason. He also excelled academically, earning a Mayor’s Scholarship in 2024 and leading his BPA team to nationals.

Crashes like the one that took the life of 17-year-old Carter Barnes leave lasting scars on families and communities. Beyond the immediate grief, families often face emotional trauma, financial burdens, and a profound sense of loss. In Idaho, such tragedies are unfortunately common. In 2023, the state experienced its deadliest year on record, with 277 traffic fatalities—the highest in two decades. These statistics underscore the importance of road safety measures and the need for increased awareness to prevent future tragedies

The icy conditions in Idaho, along with the hilly terrain, make these crashes a common occurrence. Other factors may include encounters with wildlife and close calls with other vehicles in conditions of low visibility. For those affected by serious car accidents, navigating the legal process can seem overwhelming. Montgomery Dowdle is dedicated to helping accident victims and their families seek justice and fair compensation. We understand Idaho’s personal injury laws and will fight to ensure that negligent parties are held accountable. If you or a loved one has been killed or injured in a crash, Montgomery Dowdle is ready to advocate for you.

Montgomery Dowdle: Successful Advocates for Accident Victims

At Montgomery Dowdle, we understand how quickly life can change after a serious car crash. The trauma, confusion, and grief that follow are overwhelming for many families. Our team is committed to standing by your side from the very beginning, guiding you through every legal step with focus and compassion. We have represented countless Idaho families through some of the most difficult moments of their lives.

Whether you’re facing life-altering injuries or mourning the sudden loss of loved ones, we have the firepower to secure the compensation you need to make your life normal again. We take the time to listen to your story, learn the details, and provide legal strategies that serve your unique situation. With a strong knowledge of Idaho law and a firm grasp of how insurance companies operate, we work hard to recover the compensation you deserve. Our legal team focuses on delivering results while never losing sight of the emotional toll these cases can carry. When we take on your case, our mission is to help you find clarity and confidence in the middle of chaos.

When a Family Member Dies in a Crash

Losing a loved one in a traffic collision is one of the most painful experiences anyone can endure. These situations leave families emotionally shattered and struggling to comprehend the sudden and permanent absence of the people they love. The legal issues that follow only add more stress to an already unbearable situation.

In the aftermath of such tragedies, legal action may feel like the last thing on your mind. Still, securing justice and compensation can help families cover costs and begin to rebuild. Holding the party responsible accountable may also prevent similar losses from happening to others. Idaho law allows surviving family members to pursue wrongful death claims in these cases. At Montgomery Dowdle, we walk you through this process carefully and respectfully, one step at a time.

Causes of Traffic Accidents in Idaho

In Idaho, traffic collisions are a serious concern due to rural roads, high speeds, collisions with wildlife and unpredictable weather. Many accidents happen on undivided highways with limited visibility and little lighting, particularly during winter months with snow and ice. These conditions, combined with distractions or impaired driving, make it harder for drivers to react in time, often leading to devastating consequences. This reality underscores the need for increased road safety and awareness across the state.

Rollover crashes are among the most dangerous types of traffic accidents, often leading to severe injuries or fatalities. Often, near-misses may trigger rollover crashes, which complicates issues of fault. In Idaho, rollover crashes are frequent on rural roads, where winding, narrow highways and poor weather conditions make control difficult. According to the Idaho Transportation Department, rollover crashes have a disproportionately high fatality rate due to the violent nature of the accident and the risk of ejection.

Weather Conditions in Idaho

Idaho’s weather can shift quickly, especially during spring and winter months. Sudden rain, sleet, or snowfall can make roads slick and reduce visibility. Drivers who fail to adjust to these conditions increase the risk of crashing. Black ice and freezing fog can catch even experienced drivers off guard. When roads become unpredictable, mistakes can become deadly.

️ Road Conditions & Terrain

Scenic but rural: Much of Idaho is rural with long stretches of highway, mountainous terrain, and limited cell service in remote areas.

Weather impact: Winters can be harsh with snow and ice, especially in the northern and eastern parts. Always check the weather and road conditions.

Wildlife crossings: Deer, elk, and moose are common, especially around dawn and dusk. Collisions with wildlife may cause severe damage to a car and even chain reaction accidents.

Driving in Idaho: Key Considerations

Driving in Idaho comes with real risks, especially due to changing weather and rural highways. The state’s “Basic Rule” requires drivers to adjust their speed based on current conditions, not just posted limits. Snow, ice, and freezing bridges demand extra caution during winter months. Good tires, longer following distances, and avoiding cruise control on slick roads can also help prevent a crash. Idaho also bans handheld phone use while driving to reduce distractions. Staying alert, slowing down when needed, and respecting local traffic laws can save lives on Idaho roads.

Road Conditions & Geography

Idaho’s roads span vast rural areas, mountainous regions, and scenic byways with limited infrastructure in remote locations.

Winter driving conditions can be hazardous due to snow, ice, and reduced visibility—especially in northern and eastern Idaho.

Wildlife crossings are common; collisions with deer, elk, and moose often occur at dawn or dusk. Collisions with wildlife are a common cause of damage to vehicles in many areas.

Traffic Laws & Safety Regulations

Speed Limits: Generally, 75–80 mph on interstates, 65 mph on state highways, and 25–35 mph in urban or residential zones.

Hands-Free Driving Law: Use of handheld electronic devices while driving is prohibited statewide (enforced since July 2020).

Seat Belt Requirements: All vehicle occupants are legally required to wear seat belts.

School Zone Enforcement: Reduced speed limits and flashing light indicators are strictly enforced in designated school zones.

Law Enforcement & Local Driving Practices

Idaho State Police and local law enforcement maintain a strong presence and enforce traffic laws diligently.

Driving culture tends to be courteous in smaller towns, while urban areas like Boise and Coeur d’Alene may experience more aggressive driving behaviors.

Nowadays, police in Idaho do take impaired driving very seriously. DUI laws are strictly enforced, with serious legal consequences for violations.

Fueling, Equipment & Travel Tips

Gas stations may be few and far between in rural or mountainous regions—drivers should refuel in populated areas before long trips.

During winter months, tire chains or snow tires may be required, particularly in mountainous terrain or when road conditions deteriorate.

Visitors renting vehicles are encouraged to choose 4WD or AWD options when traveling in winter or mountainous areas.

Causes of Car Accidents in Idaho

Car accidents in Idaho have a number of causes. The worst include aggressive driving, distracted driving, and impaired driving. 2023 saw an especially serious increase in traffic incidents, according to the Idaho Transportation Department. Distracted driving, such as texting or adjusting in-car technologies, continues to increase, leading to numerous accidents due to drivers’ diverted attention. Impaired driving, involving alcohol or drugs, continues to pose a grave danger on Idaho roads, with limited public transportation options in rural areas exacerbating the issue.

Additional contributing factors include failure to yield, failure to maintain lane position, and disobedience of traffic signals. Idaho’s unpredictable weather conditions, such as snow, ice, and fog, further complicates driving, leading to reduced visibility and slippery roads. Given the disastrous year of 2023, addressing these issues through public education, stricter enforcement, and improved infrastructure is crucial to enhancing road safety in Idaho

Confusing Road Layouts

Some Idaho highways and rural roads lack proper signage or have awkward curves. Drivers unfamiliar with these routes might misjudge a turn or drift into the opposite lane. Icy conditions and roads cut through hilly terrain only add to the problem. In areas where lighting is poor, spotting these hazards becomes more difficult. Confusing exits and road mergers also pose challenges. These conditions contribute to accidents when drivers react too late.

Negligent Driving is the Most Common Cause

Negligence can come from any of a variety of causes in rollover accidents in Idaho. This includes distracted driving, fatigue, or driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs. Some drivers attempt risky passes on two-lane roads without a clear view ahead, causing near misses resulting in disastrous and fatal rollovers on Idaho’s icy and mountainous roads. Others simply ignore maintaining their own vehicles or driving them properly. When drivers ignore the rules, they endanger everyone.

Fallout From These Accidents

Fatal crashes often leave behind devastation that changes lives in an instant. Families are forced to cope with the sudden loss of a loved one, while survivors may be left with catastrophic injuries. The emotional toll runs deep, affecting mental health, daily routines, and long-term stability. Recovery can take months or even years, and some never fully heal.

Beyond the emotional impact, the physical and financial consequences can be overwhelming. Victims may suffer from permanent disabilities, chronic pain, and loss of income. Medical bills pile up quickly, especially when ongoing treatment or rehabilitation is needed. These situations demand immediate action—not only from doctors but also from legal professionals who can help secure support and accountability.

Physical Injuries

Crash survivors often suffer multiple injuries, ranging from visible trauma to hidden internal damage. Medical teams work quickly to stabilize victims and treat life-threatening conditions. Even after initial care, recovery may take months or years. Injured victims often need surgeries, physical therapy, and ongoing treatment. The physical pain and uncertainty can feel relentless.

The Immediate Consequences

A high-impact collision can turn lives upside down in seconds. Victims often suffer serious injuries that require urgent medical attention and fast transport to the nearest hospital. Even with prompt care, the damage can be life-altering. Some injuries lead to long-term complications, and recovery is rarely straightforward. For families, the hours after a crash are filled with fear, uncertainty, and a desperate need for answers.

Broken Bones

Bone fractures are common in serious accidents. The force of the impact can break arms, legs, ribs, or facial bones. Healing often requires surgery, immobilization, and long-term rehabilitation.

Lacerations

Glass and metal fragments can cause deep cuts and punctures. These wounds might require stitches or more advanced care. Scarring or infections may follow even after treatment.

Permanent Injuries

Some injuries leave victims with permanent mobility limitations. These injuries change a person’s ability to live, work, and engage with their community. When injuries last a lifetime, so do the costs and complications.

Spinal Injuries

Motor vehicle accidents are the leading cause of spinal injuries, according to the Mayo Clinic. Damage to the spinal cord can result in partial or complete paralysis. These injuries often require lifelong medical care and assistive equipment. Victims must adjust to a new daily reality.

Head and Neck Injuries

Trauma to the brain or neck can impair cognition, speech, or motor skills. Even mild brain injuries can affect memory and emotional control. Severe cases may require round-the-clock care.

Paralysis

Loss of movement in the arms or legs is devastating. Paralysis can be complete or partial and affects independence. Adjusting to life after paralysis requires major emotional and financial support.

Internal Injuries that Might Not be Immediately Apparent

Some crash-related injuries remain hidden at first. Internal bleeding, organ damage, or soft tissue trauma may take hours to show symptoms. Delayed treatment can increase the risk of complications. Accident victims for this reason need to visit a physician immediately after a crash, because hidden injuries often snowball over time.

Psychological Injuries

The emotional impact of a violent crash can be just as severe as the physical harm. Many survivors experience post-traumatic stress, anxiety, or depression. Flashbacks, nightmares, and mood swings can interfere with daily life. Therapy and mental health care become vital parts of recovery. These invisible wounds deserve just as much attention as physical ones.

Long-Lasting Economic Damage

Financial fallout can be one of the most difficult parts of recovery. Even with insurance, most families aren’t prepared for the mountain of costs that follow. Accident victims often need time away from work, making it even harder to stay financially stable. Medical expenses, home modifications, and caregiving costs all add up. Without legal help, some families may never fully recover.

Medical Bills

Overall, medical expenses are the leading cause of bankruptcy in the United States. Costs for emergency treatment, follow-up care, and medications pile up fast. Surgeries and specialist visits only increase the burden. Insurance coverage is often limited, leaving families responsible for the balance.

Emergency Bills

Trips to the ER, ambulance rides, and imaging scans add up quickly. Insurance rarely covers all costs upfront. Many families find themselves buried in bills within days of the crash.

Lost Wages

Injured victims often miss weeks or months of work. For many, this setback leaves them behind for years. If the injury prevents a return to work, the financial toll grows deeper. The responsibility should lie with the liable part or their insurance company.

Legal Fees

Even pursuing justice can cost money. Court filing fees, document preparation, and specialized consultations are part of the process. That’s why Montgomery Dowdle works on a contingency basis—you pay nothing unless we win.

Life Disruption

Accidents affect more than just health and finances—they disrupt your entire life. Families might need to relocate, change jobs, or adapt to new routines. Children may be affected by emotional strain at home. Recovery becomes a full-time job, especially for caregivers. Nothing remains the same after a serious crash.

Our Insurance System Can be Problematic

Most people trust that insurance companies will help them after a crash. Unfortunately, that’s not always how it works. While insurers market themselves as being on your side, their main goal is to protect their bottom line. After an accident, insurance companies move quickly—not to help you, but to gather evidence they can use to minimize your compensation. They may ask you for recorded statements, request access to your medical records, or offer a quick settlement that’s far less than what your case is actually worth. Many accident victims don’t realize these early moves are strategic efforts to limit the insurer’s financial responsibility.

Insurance companies have teams of adjusters, investigators, and attorneys, each of whose job is to minimize liability. They’re trained to exploit any inconsistencies in your claim and may even suggest that you were partially or fully at fault for the crash. In some cases, they’ll delay responses or make the claims process so frustrating that you feel pressured to accept less than you deserve. This creates an uneven playing field where injured individuals—often dealing with physical pain and financial stress—are left at a serious disadvantage. Without legal guidance, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed and unsure of how to protect your rights. That’s why having a dedicated advocate on your side can make all the difference.

Regardless of Fault, the Insurance System is Rigged Against the Victim

Insurance companies often make lowball offers to close claims quickly. Victims may feel pressured to accept less than they need. The process is full of delays, paperwork, and confusion. Without legal help, it’s hard to know what your case is really worth. We’re here to level the playing field. In select cases, we can even advise in a consumer complaint with the Idaho Department of Insurance.

Compensation After an Insurance Claim Should Account for Every Aspect of the Loss

Real compensation isn’t just about medical bills—it includes emotional distress, long-term care, and lost income. Every case is unique and deserves review with a fine-tooth comb. Settlements should reflect the full impact of the crash. We at Montgomery Dowdle work to ensure no detail gets overlooked. Our goal is always full and fair compensation.

Insurance Companies Have Responsibilities, But They Also Have Their Bottom Line

Insurance carriers have a duty to treat claimants fairly—but they’re also businesses. Their goal is to protect profits. That conflict can work against you. We push back when insurance companies try to cut corners. You deserve someone who knows their tactics and can fight back.

How an Experienced Idaho Law Firm Can Help

Dealing with the aftermath of a deadly crash involves far more than filling out forms. It requires a law firm that knows Idaho’s legal system and has real experience handling complex wrongful death and personal injury claims. These cases aren’t simple, and families deserve legal support that is both compassionate and capable.

At Montgomery Dowdle, we aim to make the legal process easier during one of the hardest times in your life. We investigate the crash, collect crucial evidence, and build a strong case on your behalf. We’re here to stand up to insurance companies and hold the at-fault party accountable. While you focus on grieving and recovery, we handle the legal burdens with dedication and care.

Our Process: Step by Step

We start every case with a detailed consultation. That’s where we learn what happened, listen to your concerns, and identify the key legal issues. From there, we gather medical records, police reports, and witness statements. We build a solid case designed to hold the responsible party accountable. Every step we take is designed with your goals in mind.

We Prioritize Establishing a Relationship in Our Intake Process

We believe in building trust from the first conversation. Our intake process focuses on understanding your story and needs. It’s more than just forms—we talk with you directly. That connection helps us serve you better. You’re never just a case number to us.

Initial Negotiations Need Careful Treatment

The early stages of a claim are crucial. What you say or sign can affect your outcome. We handle all communication with the insurance companies. Our team ensures nothing gets missed or misunderstood. These early moves can shape your case’s future.

Montgomery Dowdle Knows How to Take Care of You

Montgomery Dowdle has built a reputation for standing strong when others hesitate. We’ve handled hundreds of personal injury claims across Idaho, guiding individuals and families through some of the most difficult moments of their lives. When you’re facing serious injuries, mounting bills, and overwhelming stress, having a team that knows when to stand firm and when to move strategically can make all the difference. Our approach is never one-size-fits-all—we take the time to understand your case and build a plan that fits your goals. Every decision we make is focused on securing the outcome you deserve.

What sets Montgomery Dowdle apart is our ability to act decisively when it matters most. We know how to evaluate a case, identify the pressure points, and pursue justice with clarity and purpose. Whether through careful negotiation or taking a case to court, we stay ready to fight for our clients every step of the way. We believe that personal injury representation should be as personal as the name suggests, which is why we stay in close communication and make sure you never feel alone in the process. With us, you have a team that’s been through this before and is committed to seeing it through with you.

When Litigation is Necessary, You Need Only the Best

Sometimes settlement talks stall. When that happens, we’re ready to take your case to court. Our attorneys have trial experience and aren’t afraid of the courtroom. We prepare every case as if it might go to trial. That preparation gives you leverage, whether we settle or litigate. You’ll always know we’re fighting for the best outcome.

We Provide Services Across Idaho

From Boise to Pocatello, our firm helps clients in cities and rural areas alike. No matter where you live, we’ll come to you if needed. Our commitment extends across the state. You shouldn’t have to travel far to get legal help. We make sure access is never a barrier.

Available for 24/7 Consultation

Accidents don’t happen on a schedule—and neither does our support. We’re available around the clock to answer your questions. Whether it’s the middle of the night or early morning, someone from our team is ready to talk. We understand the urgency these cases carry. Help is always just a call or click away.

Bilingual Personal Injury Attorneys

We’re proud to serve both English and Spanish-speaking clients. Language should never be a barrier to justice. Our bilingual attorneys help ensure that all clients fully understand their rights. We communicate clearly and respectfully. Everyone deserves equal access to legal help.

Contact Us Now for a Free Consultation

Call us now for a free consultation. Our team is ready to listen, answer your questions, and fight for the justice you deserve. When you reach out, you’ll speak with someone who understands what you’re going through and knows how to help. We take the time to understand every detail of your case and develop a personalized strategy to pursue the compensation you need for medical bills, lost wages, and the pain you’ve endured. Insurance companies have teams working against you—let us be the team working for you.

We don’t charge anything unless we win your case, so there’s no risk in reaching out. Your recovery—both physical and financial—matters to us, and we won’t back down from holding the responsible parties accountable. Whether your crash happened on a highway, in a neighborhood, or on a rural Idaho road, we’re ready to help. We are available at (208) 378-8882 or through our website. Let us help you move forward with strength, clarity, and confidence.

Teen Hockey Player Who Died in Tragic Crash Remembered by Community